Thats no good, anyways its only the first bad review i've read so far, the only other so-so one i've read the guy gave it an 8/10 though said its good not great. Everyother review i've read said its great. I do think the movie will get a bit slammed by critics or atleast wont be greeted with open arms, just doesnt seem like the type of movie critics would praise much.

Anyways I hear theres about 30min cut off the movie that will be on the dvd, not because of the violence or anything, just because it would've been too long, though I hear its some scenes fans would be gitty about.

reviews from critics shouldnt matter to much with this film as long as it is not totaly panned :wink:

One more bad review in CHUD.... [from "Grofield"]

http://chud.com/forums/showthread.php?t=75210&page=1&pp=150

Here's 7 reviews from IMDb, six were positive, one wasnt.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0401792/usercomments

Though like the last reviewer said, it seems as though a Love or hate movie.

I can confidently write that this is the most faithful comic book adaptation ever put to film.


See now I dont get that, if its so faithful, that means you dont like it because you werent fond of the novel to begin with.

16 days until Sin City opens!!!

I think that that review by Parker illustrates the danger of watching this movie and feeling the need to obsessively compare it to the graphic novels. Of course, not everyone who has read them will be as analytical as that guy, but I just feel like I'm in a better position, barely having any knowledge of Sin City.

sneak peek of Sin City tonight during Point Pleasant, 9 PM EST.

11min Making Of clip http://www.sincityfan.tk/

Another review http://www.superherohype.com/forums/sho ... p?t=166741 ( positive )

in fact, they think that it is one of the big problem.

Comparing to the comic book, cinema is a different medium and has different rules.

Miller is probably the most cinematic storytelling artist in the history of comics, though. Most storyboard artists do their sequences just like comic book artists do. The guy who did storyboards for The Matrix came directly out of the comic book field. He was fresh off drawing Spider-Man. This is why Rodriguez wanted Miller, because of his eye for the dramatic shot. Comic artists frame their shots just like they're looking through a camera lens.

First review from RT
http://www.killermoviereviews.com/main. ... ay&dId=560

That reviewer goes on and on about the violence, NICE!!! \:D/ good to see its a bloody good time, anyways he gave it a 4/5, better then Spider-Man 2 ( 3/5 )

YAY!!!!!!!!!! :rock:

totaly awesome :rock:

looks like the critics for the most part are realy going to enjoy the film :cool;

Might end up with what Sky Captan has at RT, around 70%

How the fuck can you compare a movie like SIN CITY to SPIDERMAN II?? That's apples and oranges folks..

Closest thing to it is comic book movies, so I compared it to Spider-Man

AAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHH! I can't wait for this movie!

well we will have to wait and see how things role out but I hope its average rating can be as good as Spidey 2.

The film is R rated for:

"the official rating is Rated R for Sustained Strong violence, nudity, sexual content and dialouge, this rating was attached to the trailer attached to point pleasant last night."

The reason why it says sustained strong violence is because the blood in the film will be white, and yellow for the yellow bastard. Thats all it still has all the same action packed and bloody scenes from the comic.

WOOO :woo:

cant wait anymore

lol, I know the pressure its getting ready to burst oh NO!!!!!!!!

still two weeks, NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!

BJ, Bring Sin city on, I'm in a for good entertaining movie. I am hoping Sin City will be lots of fun

It will be :wink: though the reactions have been mixed so far so I dont expect everyone to like it which means I may have to lower my prediction big time