After first watch I'll give it a B. It was a good movie and I enjoyed it. Might go up to B+ after I see it another time.

It would help to say what you thought of the previous movies in the series. To give some context.

Oh man my fav local critic hated AWE.

Oh ok...

POTC: A
POTC2: B
POTC3: B ( for now, probably will go up with second viewing )

My grade: B+

Well, the first act took some time to get into, because not everything made sense, but at the end, it was well planned out and well executed. I like it, it never got too boring at all, just a little silly at times, but still entertaining. And no, it didn't feel long to me, I thought it was just right because of all the different plots that needed to get resolved. All in all, it was a fun and exciting experience, and the execution of the ending was great, even better than the first two.

Also, don't forget to stay after the credits.

Was the extra scene after worth it? I mean, I'm seeing it as midnight, so I don't want to stay afterwards for 20 minutes of credits just for a 20 second blurb.

Just watch the last scene in the trailer forum when you get home

You could always take a nap after the movie ends, then wake up 15 minutes later to see the clip

I've just seen it second time..

I think I'd like to change my grade(s)..

No, AWE hold up very well. It's just, yesterday, I watched Pirates 1 & 2 again..

AWE stays the same at A-
while my grade for CotB is up to A- (from B+)
and DMC; B+ (from B)

definitely the most satisfied trilogy recently..

Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End

The film before the mega action sequence at the end was well, solid. While it's (refering to the film before the climax) not much of action, it's still highly entertaining. It's uneven, yes. It's weird sometime, yes. But those are really just minor problems. For me, the bigger issue is, how the story is too complicated for its own good with all those plot-twists. But then again, to be honest, this is still really just a minor problem that can be overlooked. Why? I tell you why; the battle scene at the end. It was really really truly awesome!
The casts is another this movie's improvement. And I'm glad, this one is not all about Capt. Jack.
If there's something I dislike the most; it'd be Chow Yun-Fat. He's great, actually. But... I better shut my mouth up.
Oh! did I mention the running time? I didn't, did I? Well, because throughout 168 minutes of this movie, I never felt bored. It actually didn't really feel that long.
I'm really satisfied.
**** out of ***** (A-)

The first one is a lot more charming. But this one feels a lot more 'Epic'. And I loved 'Epic'. :mrgreen:

The end battle is a bit of a letdown because all these ships are lined up and you expect a huge battle between two fleets but in the end it amounts to a simple one on one fight. Like i said the other day, nothing all that different from the battles seen before, just with a maelstrom added.

A+

Review soon!

A+

Perfect end to my all time favorite trilogy.

I couldn't have said it better myself.

I will keep this short:

Pirates 1: B
Pirates 2: A
Pirates 3: B-

This one was funnier than 1 and 2 combined, which is good. The entire success of the trilogy rests with Johnny Depp, he is hilarious. The last 30-45 minutes was very blah. Bad CGI and a boring end battle didn't leave me wowed. I was surprised at a few scenes and how violent they were, especially the scene where Davey Jones kills the captain towards the end. Also, poor use of Chow Yun-Fat.

So, it's great, great fun. More fun than Dead Man's Chest (though, without the last hour, it has nothing on Black Pearl). And it's definitely hilarious (Jack's hallucinations = GOLD). It didn't feel long at all, to be honest. Had it not been for such a confusing plot, I think it would have been perfect. Seriously, during the second hour of this film, it's hard to keep up with what's happening, who's on which side, what's the new goal, etc. I mean, in the end, it all came together and it was fine, but there were points where I felt lost. This might be improved on a second viewing, I guess. But, yeah, the final hour and final fight was spectacular. The best hour of the entire Pirates of the Caribbean trilogy. And the first hour is quite good, too, so it weights out the middle. I had a blast, overall. The series ended on a high note.

A-

Pirates 1: A
Pirates 2: A-
Pirates 3: A-

F

Absolutely worthless.

Well I thought it was great. The end battle was amazing and it was better that it was only The Black Pearl vs The Dutchmen. If it was the entire armada vs the entire pirate fleet the critics would have complained that their was too much going on. So it was a lose-lose situation with the critics but the fans will eat it up.
Every single character came back in this movie. Even the dog and the two guys from the first movie that Jack encountered in Port Royal. Was nice to see them back, I was wondering where they were in the last movie.
Is it the best in the trilogy? Too hard to tell after one viewing.

Dark spot: Not enough Keith Richards.

I gave 300 an A and I thought this was better so an A it is. Bring on Transformers to beat it.

Also, Keira is the hottest Pirate King ever. True Story.

Good Movie, my favorite of the three big May movies. Johnny Depp is still a badass. There were times when I would say I was lost and did not know exactly what was going on such as in the beginning or mostly in the middle with the pirate lords and others, but in the end it worked out. Also I liked the end, it could end the trilogy, but also open up to a 4th and 5th one.

A-

A

Better then P2. A fitting end.
Every character did an awsome job. Even Will Turner.

I can't wait for more.......in 3 or so years from now.

It's fantastic...probably better than the first. Way better than the second.

It's a phenomenal movie.

Well that's nice.

Sorry to state the truth

Really reminds me of that Family Guy episode where everyone loved Peter's play but then Louis stands up and tells everybody that they're fucking morons.