Register  |  Sign In
View unanswered posts | View active topics It is currently Thu May 15, 2025 12:30 pm



Reply to topic  [ 58 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3
 April Fools Q&A 
Author Message
Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

Joined: Fri Mar 11, 2005 10:41 am
Posts: 464
Post 
Archie Gates wrote:
If I got over it, I"m sure you can.

(edit: changed by me, no need for me to be sacrastic)

I'm not over it, I might not be able to get over it, for whatever reasons are external or mine, and that's my choice. I gave my out. I don't expect anybody to leave but maybe me. I am expressing what is frustrating to me about this situation.

Quote:
You can nitpick what she says but you are paying too much attention to the lyrics and not enough to the music.

I addressed this in my post. Dolcevita has done everything to lyrically express that she is sorry for what happened in this instance. But I'm not buying the earnesty. I'm just being honest. Do you want me to lie? She doesn't really have to say anything.


Last edited by addr0ck on Mon Apr 04, 2005 2:17 am, edited 1 time in total.



Mon Apr 04, 2005 1:48 am
Profile WWW
Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

Joined: Fri Mar 11, 2005 10:41 am
Posts: 464
Post 
dolcevita wrote:
1. I do not think general pranking on April Fools day is wrong. A misgiving about the topic chosen does not mean that i don't think a good prank next year is out of line. i have stated such.

To me that's very non-specific and raises a few potential flags.

Quote:
4. that doen't mean six months of efforts and site and forum building are negated and that in general I am the general sludge at the bottom of the barrel for eternity

Addressed in my response to Archie before this post.

Quote:
6. I understand people are mad about being tricked. I have a right to be mad about my character and all my work being retroactively smeeared.

Quite frankly, there are many here who feel that the perpetrators of this mess have no right at this moment to stand up and defend themselves and their legacy. You are only doing more to highlight and to justify this action... like every 6 months you can save up to do something really bad. You should take it personally, because this (partially) reflects your character, but it was bad form (in my opinion) to pick this moment to stand up and defend yourself. Maybe if this was still a huge issue in 2 or 3 weeks. But two days after, when the wounds are still fresh?

Again, bad form.

And again, the reason why I'm "picking" on you specifically is that you are very vocal about it. I (personally) have not mentioned your name to anybody else except bABA in private before this point.

Quote:
7. I can deal with this one issue being in fact an issue. I cannot deal with the fact that everything from the past and future are now apprently rejected. I consider myself as having given enough to the forums that one conflict of opinion will not tarnish the rest of it en masse.

This is not really a conflict of opinion. This, in many ways, to a few of us, feels like emotional manipulation, deception and something that's far more than opinion. Do you understand this?

I think you understand it on a moderator level. I think you understand that it was bad form, because it creates trouble. But I'm not quite sure you appreciate at all that some of us feel like we were trampled upon and then our thoughts and feelings on the matter were tossed away by people trying to justify why something like this was inappropriate.

Quote:
More than one person is allowed to be upset at any one point for different reasons.

I completely agree. But I think you should re-evaluate at the moment whether or not this is a good time to express that emotion. I say, "go with the feeling" and be honest, but that will get you in trouble and get you into arguments like this.

Anyway, I've said probably everything I need to say on this issue. I don't hate any of you, just confused. I may or may not be being overly dramatic about it, but it hit me pretty hard and I'm going with the moment and trying to express myself, although I know it's not coming out clearly.


Mon Apr 04, 2005 1:57 am
Profile WWW
Site Owner
User avatar

Joined: Wed Sep 15, 2004 1:09 pm
Posts: 14631
Location: Pittsburgh
Post 
The thing that bothers me addrock, is just like we were misguided and let things go badly in regards to the april fools joke ... so have many members done in dealing with it.

It is not that they don't have a right to be upset, because they do. It is not that they don't have the right to leave the forums if they so choose, because they do. It is how ignorant some of them come off in saying things. Ignorant to how hard some of the mods work, ignorant to how much time they have spent molding this place into somewhere those same posters could come, and most of all - ignorant to the character and feelings of the people involved.

Some of these mods have worked so damn hard, and given so much time to this place, that I feel awful that I put them in a position with this April Fools joke to become open to this much criticsm. If anyone deserves it, it is me. I was the one who picked the joke, I was the one who decided on the topic and game plan. I explained how we had to start early ... they went along with it, and the rest is now history.

We can't go back and change it, we have offered our apology. You don't have to take it, that is totally your choice. You don't have to believe in its sincerity, that is your choice. Me, I don't care. I wish the joke had never happened, but I apoligized for it, I have moved on, I can do nothing more. Others don't share that sentiment. There are some mods and a former mod who are really beating themselves up over this.

It bothers me to see them like this. There is NO reason someone should beat themselves up over this joke. It happened, we are all still alive, living, breathing, healthy, and mentaly sound. No long term reprocussions are going to happen to anyone, and no life changing decisions were made.

Dolce I am talking to you now ... forget Addrock and everyone else. All the moderators and anyone who knows you at all, knows your sincerity, and I will continue to feel awful until you are able to forget about this. All we can do dolce is offer our apologies and move on. If members choose to accept it, thats their choice. If they choose to leave, also their choice. DON'T beat yourself up over it Dolce .... you have done all you can.


Mon Apr 04, 2005 2:27 am
Profile WWW
2.71828183

Joined: Mon Oct 11, 2004 9:16 pm
Posts: 7827
Location: please delete me
Post 
dolcevita wrote:
And members have expressed a consideration that mods were akin to teacher in positions or authority. so now its known.

Agreed. As above, its been a learning experience. There was no precedence and no one here has been modding for years and seen this stuff happen before to have known otherwise. So only all the assurance can be placed in the future.


Good, one very important positive about the mods here, and they do actually listen to members.

Quote:
The rules were independant of the prank. they came from the members requests and had nothing to do with it. As I memtion repeatedly, the mods and admin conduct in regards to the memebers is otherwise excellent, and I think it would have been more upsetting if we'd postponed putting rules that had been requested up until, say, today, just because we were planning a prank. None of that has anything to do with this, unless anyone has issues with those aspects, and that should be in its own thread or notified via pm, it still should have nothing to do with this.


I think you and I will just have to agree we do not see eye to eye on this.

Quote:
Yes, and its a shame we didn't think of it earlier. But thats what happened, I can't make excuses (or at least any good ones that is) for it. And if britney spears was a member here, she'd probably find the prank offensive, so its a good thing i have more respect for almost everyone here than i do for britney spears.


She might, but the weddign is alot more tongue and cheek from description then the wedding sounds, and hey there is always next year for weddings.

Quote:
I can't speak for them, but I'll continue to dish out my adivice all the same if some asks. Its a personal judgement call. I'll keep talking in fact as you can see from my ridiculously high post count, its pretty hard to shut me up. But some people probably won't. I can't blame them either, and don't care to. The only singular fault I've had in the whole ordeal is to hear months of work disrespected and torn down over one lapse in judgement. That I can blame people for, but they don't have to listen to me. I'll say it anyways.


I think the fact the everyone respects the work that came before might be why some of them feel the need to leave, if that makes sense.\

Quote:
I'll still talk, just maybe not between March 27th and April 1st. And even then I probably would, but thats a personal reflection. I'm not speaking for anyone else, and everyone else does and should take it differently.


Honestly I think we'll find in a week or two, thaton surface not much has changed around here.

Quote:
I noticed, but it didn't affect me much as advice, as I've never dated someone in the office before. I have limited experience in anything in general, so have limited ways in which I can expose myself. I have said vulnerable stuff about myself, the operation, etc, because I chose to. I thought someone would get something out of it. Maybe they did, probably they didn't. Thats out of my hands. We make assumptions based on our own experiences and opinions.


Agreed

Quote:
Would you prefer we normally be dirty and bad then? As I said, I can only speak for myself when I say did intend emotion and not complete passivity, I just didn't anticipate the after affects. Yes, that's manipulative, yes its for april fools, yes, i was a mod. After the event, I can soundly respond to the same question with a resounding no. Its been established mods should act differently, and that a double account for a swimfan prank, or other forum members pranks, are not the same as a mod prank. i don't think to highly of st. patricks day, some people don't like april fools day.


I don;t like St. Patrick's Day either, but we have city here in RI where every eyar people drink so much that the beer runs out at 5pm, no matter how muchyou more you order then last year....

Quote:
Well, then yes, i am naive. I didn't think people would relate to it personally or indirectly, I thought the emotion would come out of the conjectures. I anticipated most of the energy coming from people disagreeing with suggestions.


That I can at least understand, so I appreciate that level of clarification.

Quote:
Well, a prank usually involves someone not being in on it, as I was never in on one before and have often been on the receiving end. But again, while I personally can't condemn any memebers who want to do something on the day, I agree I may not have been in the proper position for it (see first post about your teacher). I agree that after the prank there was alot of commotion that wasn't necessarily handled well. I for one blanked and didn't even think to send people private messages. The first time I even thought about it was when a memeber posted about how two members had contacted him, and that (s)he was surprised who else hadn't. Yep, I hadn't. I don't pat myself on the back for it. I do quite the opposite. I can also say the same goes for memebers who refuse to take our sincere, however discombobulated, response to heart.


Agreed, I actually respect the apologizes jsut as much as I respect loyal who refuses to apologize.

Honestly for me, I;ve relly said all I need to say on the subject. I plan to devote my time here to talking about other things, but I apperciate your responses.


Mon Apr 04, 2005 8:16 am
Profile
Commander and Chef

Joined: Mon Oct 11, 2004 12:56 am
Posts: 30505
Location: Tonight ... YOU!
Post 
Eagle wrote:
The thing that bothers me addrock, is just like we were misguided and let things go badly in regards to the april fools joke ... so have many members done in dealing with it.

It is not that they don't have a right to be upset, because they do. It is not that they don't have the right to leave the forums if they so choose, because they do. It is how ignorant some of them come off in saying things. Ignorant to how hard some of the mods work, ignorant to how much time they have spent molding this place into somewhere those same posters could come, and most of all - ignorant to the character and feelings of the people involved.

Some of these mods have worked so damn hard, and given so much time to this place, that I feel awful that I put them in a position with this April Fools joke to become open to this much criticsm. If anyone deserves it, it is me. I was the one who picked the joke, I was the one who decided on the topic and game plan. I explained how we had to start early ... they went along with it, and the rest is now history.

We can't go back and change it, we have offered our apology. You don't have to take it, that is totally your choice. You don't have to believe in its sincerity, that is your choice. Me, I don't care. I wish the joke had never happened, but I apoligized for it, I have moved on, I can do nothing more. Others don't share that sentiment. There are some mods and a former mod who are really beating themselves up over this.

It bothers me to see them like this. There is NO reason someone should beat themselves up over this joke. It happened, we are all still alive, living, breathing, healthy, and mentaly sound. No long term reprocussions are going to happen to anyone, and no life changing decisions were made.

Dolce I am talking to you now ... forget Addrock and everyone else. All the moderators and anyone who knows you at all, knows your sincerity, and I will continue to feel awful until you are able to forget about this. All we can do dolce is offer our apologies and move on. If members choose to accept it, thats their choice. If they choose to leave, also their choice. DON'T beat yourself up over it Dolce .... you have done all you can.


Most of what he said Dolce. Its true. Don't beat yourself over it. You did what you could. : )


Mon Apr 04, 2005 8:35 am
Profile WWW
Kypade
User avatar

Joined: Sat Oct 30, 2004 10:53 pm
Posts: 7908
Post 
While yes, what Eagle says is true, the point addrock is making is equally valid.

**l typed out a long, thoughtful response to back that up with, but really l just don't care anymore. Wasn't much more than what andaroo's said in his last 3 or 4 posts, anyway. So reread those.


Tue Apr 05, 2005 1:42 am
Profile
Site Owner
User avatar

Joined: Wed Sep 15, 2004 1:09 pm
Posts: 14631
Location: Pittsburgh
Post 
There is nothing wrong with what Addarock said. What he feels is true for him.

The fact remains that this is going to be different for everyone. Some will feel hurt, while others could care less. However even if 366 members couldn't have gave a rats ass, if that last member felt hurt because of something I did, then I need to step back - take a look at what happened - and figure out why.

Obviously I didn't see this coming before hand, hell I really april fooled my damn self with this mess. Once you hurt just that single poster, it is a rather big wakeup call. For me the joke stoped being funny when I found out how upset it made Ripper, before that I thought things were going dandy. It wasn't until then that I took a step back, looked around at what I had done wrong, and tried to fix it. Unfourtunatly it was beyond anyons control to manipulate at that point. Me and Dolce and everyone else have said our peace, and while Addarock has many valid points, all we can do is understand where he is coming from, accept his position, and hope he can understand it from our point of view and why it happened.


Tue Apr 05, 2005 3:32 am
Profile WWW
Extraordinary
User avatar

Joined: Sat Oct 16, 2004 12:52 am
Posts: 25990
Post 
Sorry to bump it up.


I'm ok now. Eight days off was good. I have more spare time now, so I'll move over to concentrating on box office matters rather than other 'stuff'. I wish to have contact with others in that way. The way I figure, if a group of people spends that much of their time on playing a joke on the forum members, that is a clear sign that we are (well, I am) getting uncomfortably close. Early apologies if I seem impersonal from here on (or if I ignore you altogether), I just want to concentrate on the box office. Here and at BOM, of course (I had promised some users there that I would continue my coverage in December, but had a heavy load of work until now prevented me from doing so; I want to make good on the promise).


Cheers :Drink:

p.s., to the one who sent me the PM: an apology was absolutely not necessary from you, but thank you for it, it was well-taken.

And Tony, you were right, were would we all be without my signature confirming your comedic talents??? It's unthinkable that anyone should abandon that [-X =;

_________________
In order of preference: Christian, Argos

MadGez wrote:
Briefs. Am used to them and boxers can get me in trouble it seems. Too much room and maybe the silkiness have created more than one awkward situation.


My Box-Office Blog: http://boxofficetracker.blogspot.com/


Sat Apr 09, 2005 12:35 pm
Profile WWW
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Reply to topic   [ 58 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 87 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
cron
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group.
Designed by STSoftware for PTF.