http://www.petitiononline.com/StopAsh/petition.html

I find this hilarious myself. It's not like they will drop her, but the amount of sigs is huge. Sign it yourself, see how high it can get.

To stop her career, right?

I Signed.

Thats the most pathetic thing ive possibly seen....ever.
People need to leave that poor girl alone, sure shes not talented and her songs suck, but shes still young and no one that age deserves the kind of pressure shes getting.

People's attitude towards her has made me respect her more.


A littttttle more.

I feel bad for her. Sure, she doesn't have the best voice, but Hilary Duff's, among others, is just as bad and no one gives her any crap about it. She doesn't deserve that kind of thing. If people hate her, don't buy her CD, and change the station when her songs come on. It's as simple as that.

At least Ashlees voice isnt as synthesized as such artists as Duff, who all sing with backing tapes anyway. I mean, people booing her at the Orange Bowl? Hmm.... Good on you America, thats it make yourself feel better by slaughtering a teenage girl in front of millions of viewers.

Although that said...the uk tabloids do that daily

Tragic.


Funny tho.

Amen.

Sorry, but she chose to be famous and I don't feel the least bit sorry for her.

The people expected a good half time show and what they got was probably william hung-esque singing. She deserved what she got at the Orange Bowl and Jon said it perfectly about she chose this path so live with it.

Simon Cowell commented on her:

"Why should you have to do something substandard just for the sake of being real? If it sounds better with the vocal you recorded, why shouldn't people listen to that? There's almost a witch-hunt mentality about people miming."

Here

I am quite fed up of fans of so called rock music having this mentality that because they like rock music, then its by far the best kind of music.

In terms of accomplishment, there is no genre that can surpass classical music, sure its not mainstream but the point is, theres a big crowd of very talented musicians making music together. Rock music is more about the statement the music is trying to make, the fact its a counter to pop music and the social relevance in society.

Point and match being that to one person, a great alltime smash classic is utter crap to someone else. Only the highest calibre songs can appeal over many genres and demos, but musical tastes is always something were people are going to be deadset on their genre, and totally close minded.


But victimising a teenage girl for all the problems of pop music [hey, even some rock artists lip] is just stupid.

I signed lol

76470 Signatures Total

funny though LOL

NOTE: I siogned it, then ONE second later, i viewed signatures, there was 100 more after mine, that is incredible people really do hate her!!

i think her main problem is not the fact that she sings bad or is a hack or riding on the success of of her sister or lip synching. my issue with her will always remain that she freaking blamed her band!!! i mean, you dont put blame on part of your team unless you include yourself in it, or you say there was a problem or something, you don't point a finger and say "They did it!"

There's now over 107,000 signatures and it's the most active petition on the site

im sure 107,000 signatures, of which around 105,500 are of rock music loving males, is going to make Geffen drop one of their most profitable artists in recent years.

Whatever.

I know that, but still, it's pretty high.

I'm #132111. :razz:

It's not going to do anything, obviously, but it's funny, and she does infact suck.

That's quite an unfortunate name you have there. :wink:

I signed it a few days ago, I'm somewhere around 82000

If she sees the petition, it will make her upset and cry, just think if you were her. I feel for her.

I'm half and half. I feel for her, because everyone knows how it feels to fail, and most know how it feels to fail horribly. But, like others said, she chose it. Everyone makes mistakes, she just made one in front of the world.