Of the 10 yearly winners, there was 4 natural pairs, leaving... Toy Story 3 and the Favourite. Obviously having nothing to do with each other, but it just so happened two of the strongest losers fit them perfectly. Inside Out effectively tied Mad Max in its matchup, so it gets another chance here as a wild card.

Which Pixar film that made you cry is superior?



Toy Story 3 (2010 winner)



Inside Out (Wild Card)

As much as I love Inside out I think Toy Story 3 was superior for a second sequel and successfully managed to close out Andy's arc while still leaving room for expansion. I'll go with Toy Story 3

Inside Out got me to tear up multiple times.
TS3 not once.

Inside Out FTW

Inside Out is a perfect movie.

Inside Out just feels like a small movie. Like they could have done more with the world and characters. Still great, but had more potential. Toy Story 3 is pretty much perfect.

Bing Bong

I am very torn on this. I really love Toy Story 3, but ultimately I feel Inside Out reaches a highest peak.

Looks like Inside Out is winning this handily.

I fell asleep twice during Inside Out. I love TS3 though. Best film of 2010.

Tough. Inside Out was stellar, but TS3 was perfect. Toy Story 3.

toy story 3

Toy Story 3 was the perfect ending to the franchise, so I have to vote for it.

Toy Story 3, but I actually don't care much about either one. Inside Out is pretty overrated, IMO.

Pixar has never gone higher, and likely won't for many years. If only Wall-E's second half was as great as the first.
Both are true masterpieces, but my personal favourite remains Toy Story 3.

Coco

TS3 made a last minute surge

THIS IS A SHAM.

Chippy has started creating multiple accounts to vote for Inside Out

Toy Story 3 wins

Inside Out