You're close. I love The Truman Show and I liked The Insider (I find Heat, Manhunter, and Collateral better). I've never seen Lone Star (so you got the part about viewings right

)
Um, you've got a broad taste, but I don't see MANY comedies on your lists of movies you recently watched, so...:
1. The Producers (the raunchy pick)
2. Best in Show (the funniest pick)
3. About a Boy or As Good As It Gets or High Fidelity or Say Anything (the heart-warming pick

)