Great list! Seems "The Libertine" (or at least Johnny Depp) might just be headed for an Oscar nomination...
Maverikk wrote:
1. Best picture = big picture. True. Think epic ("Titanic"), think laden with costumes ("The Last Emperor"), think butt-numbingly long (the longest nominated film wins about half of the time).
Okay, this one doesn't *quite* fit with TL, though it *is* laden with costumes and I believe is rather long.
Quote:
2. Best picture = $100 million. Only one champ in the past six years did not reach that sum at the U.S. box office as of Oscar night ? the one, ironically, with "million dollar" in its title: "Million Dollar Baby."
Nope, I don't think there's much of a chance for TL on this one. Firstly, it comes out fairly late in the season (mid-January) and we're still unsure of exactly *how* wide it will go, depending on the rating it receives...
Quote:
3. Best picture winners have the most nominations. Usually. That's been the case 17 times in the past 20 years.
Don't know about the Oscars yet, but TL ties for most nominations for the BIFA (8 noms).
Quote:
4. Know the name behind the film. There's often one person strongly identified with a best picture nominee, usually a director, sometimes a star or even a producer. Name brands carry a lot of weight in this town.
Ah. Now this one definitely refers to TL... It's got a star--Johnny Depp, and it *also* has Harvey Weinstein (not as a producer, but as a major backer and dedicated campaigner).
Quote:
5. If that person is a studly actor who just took up directing, his movie's automatically nominated ?
Nothing here.
Quote:
6. Best picture victor often takes a top acting trophy. Such was the case with "American Beauty" (Kevin Spacey) and "Shakespeare in Love" (Gwyneth Paltrow). But there were times when the truism didn't hold ("Chicago" and "Titanic").
Won't know this one yet.
Quote:
7. Voters have no sense of humor. Choosing winners is serious business, and comedies rarely get the last laugh.
Yeah, TL's got it here; definitely a majorly serious drama.
Quote:
8. Film critics' awards affect the Oscars.
Well, we'll be seeing soon enough.
Quote:
9. The Golden Globes predict the Oscars. In recent decades, two-thirds of Oscar's best actors and actresses and nearly three-quarters of the best picture champs won Globes just weeks earlier. But remember, this rule isn't as cut-and-dried as it sounds: The Globes have two sets of best picture awards ? for drama and comedy/musical.
With the changes of release date for TL, I don't know if it'll end up making the deadline for nomination in the GG's. We'll have to see on that one. *But*... I can see Johnny Depp getting nominated in the Best Actor for Comedy award with CatCF, and maybe even a nomination for CatCF in the Best Picture for Comedy.
Quote:
10. Guild awards are the best predictors.
Again, we'll have to see.
Quote:
11. Keep it real. Academy members may earn millions by putting fantasy on-screen, but when it comes to the Oscars, they like contenders based on real people and events.
Here we go! TL is based on a very real person and very real events. And Depp's performance is rumored to be a brilliant portrayal of the man the movie is about.
Quote:
12. Hug a hooker. Not only is prostitution the world's oldest profession, it's one of the oldest tricks for bagging a best actress trophy.
I don't think TL quite has any qualifications in this category...
Quote:
13. Embrace the handicapped. Especially if they're guys. Think Geoffrey Rush, Daniel Day-Lewis, Tom Hanks and many others.
Not handicapped, but Depp's character suffers (and pretty much disentegrates) from a terminal disease (at least, terminal in that day and age).
Quote:
14. Drink up. Booze plays a lead role in rehab-happy Hollywood: sometimes villainous ("The Lost Weekend," "Affliction"), sometimes glamorous ("Sideways," "Lost in Translation"), but almost always worth a vote.
If I've heard correctly, Depp's character is a drunk...
Quote:
15. Bet on the babes; give the heartthrobs the heave-ho.
This one might be detrimental, as Depp is definitely one of those heartthrob guys. But the following "rule" I believe makes up for it...
Quote:
16. Win ugly. Some of Hollywood's most lovely leading ladies have been awarded for knowing they must temporarily forfeit their beauty and play against type. Just ask Charlize Theron or Hilary Swank.
As the film progresses, Depp's character succumbs to syphillis, and I believe even loses a nose. I've heard he's almost unrecognizable by the last scenes of the movie.
Quote:
17. Play favorites. Voters certainly do. They cheered on Julia Roberts to expose corporate corruption in "Erin Brockovich." They even rooted for Catherine Zeta-Jones ("Chicago") and Russell Crowe ("Gladiator") to get away with murder.
Don't quite know if Depp's a favorite, but he *has* been nominated two times in a row... This would be his third consecutive nomination.
Quote:
18. Best picture nominees are usually released at year's end. This assumes that most voters are old and have short memories.
Ah, this one works, too. TL is released in NYC/LA Nov. 25 for a one-week run, but then it doesn't go wide until January 13, 2006. Definitely working in its favor, I believe.
***
Well, now, I *believe* that gives "The Libertine" and/or Johnny Depp about 50/50 chance at this point. However, as many of these "rules" dealt with basing on nominations/wins from other awards and the nominations at the Oscars, I'll have to come back to this list and see how TL does...
But, hey, I think at the very least, Johnny Depp has a chance at a Best Actor Oscar... Third time's the charm, eh?
Joy