You aren't alone. As of now, this should win Best Pic. It is the best movie this year, hand down.

The (new) best movie of the year: Sideways

That brings it up to 3 (Eternal Sunshine, Garden State, Sideways) films I would consider Oscar-worthy this year.

Here ya go!
Picture:
Passion
Shrek 2
Terminal
Collateral
Ray
The Incredibles
Enternal Sunshine

Director:
Gibson Passion
Spielsburg Terminal
Mann Collateral

Actor:
Tom Hanks Terminal
Jim Cavizel Passion
Jim Carrey Enternal Sunshine
Kurt Russel Miracle
Jamie Foxx Collateral
Tom Cruise Collateral
Jamie Foxx Ray

Actress:
Natlie Portman Garden State
Uma Thurman Kill Bill 2

Sup. Actor:
Peter O'Toole Troy
David Caradine Kill Bill 2

Sup. Actress:
Mai M. The Passion

adapt screenplay:
Passion
Spider-Man 2

orig. screenplay:
Shrek 2
Terminal
Collateral
Ray
The Incredibles
Enternal Sunshine

Art Direction:
Passion
80 Days
Troy
Hidalgo
King Aurther
Vanity Fair
Sky Captain

Costume:
Passion
Troy
80 Days
King Aurther
Princess Diaries 2
Vanity Fair
Sky Captain

Sound:
Passion
Troy
Van Helsing
Day After Tomorow
Kill Bill 2
Man on Fire
Spiderman 2
King Aurther
I, Robot
Bourne Supremacy
Collateral
Manchurian Canadite
Village
Sky Captain
Ladder 49
Forgotten
Ray
Team America
Incredibles

Sound Editing:
Passion
Shrek 2
Troy
Van Helsing
Day After Tommorow
Spiderman 2
Collateral
Sky Captain
Ladder 49
Forgotten
Team America
Incredibles
SAW
The Grudge

Cinemetogrophy:
Passion
Troy
Alamo
Hidalgo
80 Days
King Aurther
Sky Captain
Ladder 49
Friday Night Lights

Score:
Passion
Terminal
Sky Captain
Incredibles

Editing:
Passion
Terminal
Sky Captain
Collateral
Friday Night Lights
The Forgotten
Ray
The Grudge

Makeup:
Passion
Van Helsing
Hellboy

Animated Feature:
Shrek 2
Home on the Range
Sharks Tale
Incredibles

Visual Effects:
Day After Tommorow
Spiderman 2
I, Robot
Sky Captain
Ladder 49