Which one do you think is the best singer?

I think Anne Hathaway's voice is the most "Broadway" and natural of the three - and probobly the most acomplished too. Lohans is the more Britney Spearish one and Duffs is totally over pro-tooled.

So id rank em
1. Hathaway
2. Lohan
3. Duff

Hillary Duff is annoying.

Lindsay Lohan is good but she needs to choose her songs better.

Haven't heard Hathaway yet.

Lohans voice is processed. More subtly than Duffs ultra obvious toning, but still...

Hathaway has the most natural and vocally potent voice out of the trio by a long shot - even if it is quite bland

Hathaway does have the best voice of the three. There is no doubt about that. Lindsay Lohan's voice is okay, nothing special, and same for Hilary Duff. But Duff's voice improved from her first album. Her voice sounds better on her second album, and it doesn't sound as computerized as her voice on the first album did.

1. Anne Hathaway
2. Lindsay Lohan
3. Hilary Duff

None.

Hillary Duff v Lindsay Lohan v Anne Hathaway

all doable

#1 Hillary
#2 Lindsay
#3 Anne

Haven't heard Hathaway.

Duff and Lohan both have no talent in music.

That's not very nice. They worked just as hard to get into the business as anyone else.

No they didn't, they are "cute" girls exploiting themselves in an industry which lays down a red carpet for them because they can make them money.

They are not playing gigs at local bars, working on their craft, they were child actresses chosen mostly for their looks, coasting to the music charts on their fame. Market divisions of major Multi-national Companies are focused on making at least two of these girls money making machines.

Your comment is incredibly disrespectful to any stuggling artist out there, who is working themselves to the bone for a chance they will probably never have.

First of all no they didn't.

Second of all, YAY that's great news for my music career. That means that even though my voice sounds like a cross between William hung and that guy on the phone in The Ring, by the time I'm 40 at the latest I should be a megastar :-D

Lohan is ok, if she made better music.

Don't know about Hathaway.

Lindsay Lohan and Hillary Duff are a record labels wet dream.
Two young teenagers willing to sign a cheap deal [because they already have tonnes of money]
more importantly, two young teenagers with massive installed fanbases waiting to be exploited through their music; Lohan and Duff are artists that pretty much do whatever big labels tell them too and the whole idea that they "worked hard" to get into the recording industry is piffle - the record labels are likely to have went knocking on the door first.

I have respect for pop artists like Madonna, Britney, Christina and whoever else because after years of bloody hard work these people got themselves into really, really bad record deals; they made the record label a shitload of money and after realising that they weren't actually gaining anything from the deals they went on the global assault of media manipulation and have made their $ from elsewhere; now these artists are or have come to the end of their original record label term - they finally have some sort of creative freedom and present different sounds and images.

Lohan and Duff just seem so insincere in what they do and how they sound.

Haven't heard Anne Hathaway. Lindsay Lohan and Hilary Duff both couldn't sing well if their lives depended on it. Everything you hear from them is purely electronic to make them sound passable.

Fortunately for Lohan, she can act. I can't say the same for Hilary Duff.

Possibly your cattiest remark ever

Don't let the Duffites see this one they will contest that she is going to win an oscar