Very solid pilot. It's definitely off to a good start. Am looking forward to more. I'd give the pilot a B+.

The pilot was great and very creepy. Then again, I would literally watch Connie Britton in anything because I love her so much, so my opinion might be biased

I enjoyed the show. There were some parts that were Wicker Man weird and campy but thats what makes it entertaining. Its nowhere as bad as the critics made it out to be

Good pilot, but parts of it felt a bit too fast, too soon on certain scares. It might've worked better with a more subtle pilot episode. A more creepy atmosphere and less all-out frights.

And I've filled my lifetime quota of seeing Dylan McDermott's bare ass.

The pilot was...all right, I s'pose. It had great individual moments, but was far too busy, crowded, and swiftly paced. It had so many big moments, they ceased to seem very big at all. For example, the mother having sex with her "husband" in the S&M suit...you know a TV show is in a weird place when such a creepy violation is just, "Eh, another scene." Or the way the cutter daughter's relationship with the disturbed teen was born within the space of one cut. It was almost whiplash-inducing. If this series wants to endure, it needs to slow down, let character beats have breathing room, and concentrate on building an overall suspense and atmosphere rather than just BAM! WHAM! SNAP! assaulting the viewers' eyes and ears every split second.

This was just...wacky.

I enjoyed Connie Britton, seeing Dylan McDermott without clothes and Jessica Lange acting like a crazy nutbag. But it doesn't strike me as a series that can really develop.

I thought it was really good and enjoyable. I'll definitely be watching next week.

I still don't think Ryan Murphy and Co. can follow through on an idea. I loved Nip/Tuck and Glee in their early days, but never felt compelled to keep watching after a season or two. I hope he proves me wrong here.

The writing pedigree is impressive though: X-Files vet James Wong and Whedon regular Tim Minear are among the writing staff.

LOVED the second episode. I thought it was better than the pilot.

I thought both episodes were awesome. IMHO the best new drama show this season so far.

Im still waiting for the kid with a he-man hairdo proclaiming that he wants pancakes while doing karate kicks in the air

Third episode wasn't that great but the next looks much better.

I think I found my replacement for DH next season (well, if this survives another season).

Tonight's episode was insanely entertaining.

Last night's episode was great. Zachary Quinto was awesome and I loved all the twists. This is becoming quite addicting.

I say this is the best episode of the show so far.

I didn't care for the stereotypical portrayal of the gay guys. I hated these characters. They were bitches .

Good episode though. Poor Addie . If she'd just went as Snoopy that might not have happened .

Last night's episode was insane. Easily the best one yet. The twist at the end was awesome. Also great seeing Ashley Rickards on this show (she's great on MTV's wonderful "Awkward").

Batshit insane...... this show keeps getting better.

+1

When I saw in the credits she was going to be on I was excited.

Anyway, I'm not gaga over this show. It's solid, but hasn't lived up to its promise after the premiere, IMO. I'll still keep watching it though.

Great episode tonight. I thought the opening scene was incredibly disturbing.

This episode was almost as good as the Halloween 2, but holy shit at that opening scene talk about disturbing!.

I also loved that every character had a different storyline and while the Tate storyline was only a subplot the last episode in this one really took the front seat and proves once again that it's the best storyline of the show so far.

Now taht both Violet and Vivien(she will figure it out in the next episode I think) know I wanna see how this is all gonna turn out.

Another great episode btw.

Holy shit, this episode was too much. Poor Vivien, Hayden is such a bitch bt it was nice to see the ghost actually interacting.

TATE is the rubber man?!?!?!?! so that means he knows he's dead?.

I think this rivals the halloween episodes as the best so far.

Last week's episode was INSANE. I hate Violet now - and I hope that anyone who was a fan of Tate has changed their tune. He's a sick and disgusting individual. I also think Violet is dead as there's been a spoiler going around that one of the main characters has been dead for several weeks now and will realize it later, and also because it was foreshadowed with the mention that she hadn't been to school in several weeks, etc.

I hope Vivian makes it out of everything OK though. The episode really made you sympathize with her.

Also LOVING Kate Mara as Hayden. So entertaining.