I would LMAO if Lazaro wins this in the face of how stacked against the guys the show has tried to make it so that a girl wins.

Lazaro winning would be legitimately the most embarrassing thing that's ever happened on television. Which is kind of why I want it to happen.

It would make my life.

Lazaro should be gone but it's probably gonna be Janelle.

Candace is okay for me. She has a good voice but Amber blows her voice away.
Angie has a very good voice too. I think it will come down to Kree and Amber though. That's what I will hope for.

In what universe? That performance of "Love Song" was above and beyond anything Amber has ever done, and probably ever will do.

Round 1
1. Candice
2. Amber
3. Angie
4. Kree
5. Janelle
6. Lazaro

Round 2
1. Candice
2. Angie
3. Kree
4. Amber
5. Janelle
6. Lazaro


That last performance by Candice was insane!. Simply amazing.
Hopefully these HORRIBLE performances by Lazaro gets him the boot... but unfortunetly i kind of see Janelle going home

If anyone but Lazaro goes home, they're getting saved.

Lazaro's "Close to You" was the worst thing I've seen in the finals of American Idol...EVER. Worse than John Stevens' "Crocodile Rock." Worse than Camile Velasco. Worse than Kristy Lee Cook. Worse than Sanjaya.

Whereas Candice's "Lovesong" was one of the greatest performance I've seen in the finals...EVER. lol. Comical. That was a hall of fame moment. Can join Kelly Clarkson's "Stuff Like That There," Fantasia's "Summertime," Carrie Underwood's "Alone," Bo Bice's "In a Dream," Melinda Doolittle's "My Funny Valentine," Jordin Sparks' "I Who Have Nothing," David Cook's "Always Be My Baby," Kris Allen's "Heartless" and Adam Lambert's "Mad World."

Also, WTF drugs was Mariah was on last night? Jay-sus. She made Paula Abdul seem lucid.

The funny thing about Mariah is that she's actually making some great points, she's just completely inarticulate and blabbers on instead of being able to be more concise.

Yeah, Mariah has some awful case of verbal diarrhea; which is too bad because she actually tries to critique. Just make next year the final season and have Keith Urban, J.Lo (I actually liked her when she gets to mention technical aspects of a performance only that she was WAY too nice and forgiving), and Simon Cowell as the panel. lol

They should have just signed Candice to a record label last night.

Janelle doesnt deserve the save and i dont think she is getting it.

Janelle doesnt deserve the save and i dont think she is getting it.

It would be kind of crazy if Lazaro and Janelle went next. Would they bother using the save? I mean I like Janelle, but she's not worth a save. Neither is Lazaro, obviously.

Well, looky here. A girl is officially going to win American Idol again.

So happy he is finally gone!

The list of top rated Season 12 performances on whatnottosing.com (kinda like an Idol metacritic) amuses me:

1 Lovesong - Candice Glover, 95

2 I (Who Have Nothing) - Candice Glover, 89

3 Ordinary People - Candice Glover, 87

4 Don’t Make Me Over - Candice Glover, 85

5 A Natural Woman - Candice Glover, Stronger - Kree Harrison, 81

7 You Keep Me Hangin' On - Janelle Arthur, 80

8 Up To The Mountain - Kree Harrison, Cause I Love You - Vincent Powell, Come Together - Candice Glover, 78

One might think that Candice is a critic's favourite. Incidentally, "Love Song"'s current approval rating (it could very well go down) puts it at a shared #1 position with "Stuff Like That There" and "Billie Jean".

Bye-bye, Janelle. No idea how they're going to finish the show on time now, but hey. >.>

Yeah wouldn't this end the season on 5/9?

From now on, its going to be a damn shame whoever ends up sent home.

Go Angie!

Fantastic performances. Nicki was kind of a bitch to poor Kree tonight. Based on this weeks performance, i say Kree is going to go home.

I bet we are getting a top 3 finale, thats the twist for sure

Sorry American Idol/Kree, but Procol Harum is not a one-hit wonder.

And LOL @ using the Donna Summer version of MacArthur Park when the one-hit wonder was Richard Harris.

Nitpicky... but it was irritating.

ah well... She will be missed

Go Angie!. So glad she sang Diamonds, sucks that wasnt as good as her YouTube video.

Amber's downfall was the downfall of many talented vote-offs on Idol: no connection with the audience. She just didn't have it. She had a great voice, but the voice only takes you so far. You have to be likable.