1. "Fantasy" (Mariah Carey, Chris Frantz, Tina Weymouth, Dave Hall, Adrian Belew, Steven Stanley) – 4:04
   2. "Underneath the Stars" (Carey, Walter Afanasieff) – 3:33
   3. "One Sweet Day" (with Boyz II Men) (Carey, Michael McCary, Nathan Morris, Wanya Morris, Shawn Stockman, Afanasieff) – 4:42
   4. "Open Arms" (Steve Perry, Jonathan Cain) – 3:30
   5. "Always Be My Baby" (Carey, Jermaine Dupri, Manuel Seal) – 4:18
   6. "I Am Free" (Carey, Afanasieff) – 3:09
   7. "When I Saw You" (Carey, Afanasieff) – 4:24
   8. "Long Ago" (Carey, Dupri) – 4:34
   9. "Melt Away" (Carey, Babyface) – 3:42
  10. "Forever" (Carey, Afanasieff) – 4:00
  11. "Daydream Interlude" (Fantasy Sweet Dub mix) (Carey, Frantz, Weymouth, Hall, Belew, Stanley) – 3:04
  12. "Looking In" (Carey, Afanasieff) – 3:35