1. Shrek - $441,226,247
2. Spider-Man 2 - $373,585,825
3. The Passion of the Christ - $370,274,604
4. The Incredibles - $252,317,635
5. Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban - $249,541,069
6. The Day After Tomorrow - $186,740,799
7. The Bourne Supremacy - $176,236,842
8. Meet the Fockers - $170,073,210
9. Shark Tale - $160,824,920
10. The Polar Express - $156,065,725
11. National Treasure - $155,554,422
12. I, Robot - $144,801,023
13. Troy - $133,378,256
14. 50 First Dates - $120,908,074
15. Van Helsing - $120,177,084
16. Fahrenheit 9/11 - $119,194,771
17. Dodgeball: A True Underdog Story - $114,326,736
18. The Village - $114,197,520
19. The Grudge - $110,175,871
20. Ocean's Twelve - $108,747,000
21. Collateral - $101,005,703
22. Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events - $96,816,884
23. The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement - $95,170,481
24. Starsky & Hutch - $88,237,754
25. Along Came Polly - $88,097,164
26. Mean Girls - $86,050,784
27. Anchorman - $85,224,248
28. Scooby-Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed - $84,198,209
29. Spongebob Squarepants Movie - $82,143,196
30. The Notebook - $81,001,787
31. Alien vs. Predator - $80,282,231
32. Man on Fire - $77,911,774
33. The Terminal - $77,196,021
34. Garfield: The Movie - $75,369,588
35. Ladder 49 - $73,870,841
36. Christmas with the Kranks - $73,283,281
37. Ray - $71,695,100
38. White Chicks - $69,897,980
39. Hidalgo - $67,303,450
40. The Forgotten - $66,641,205
41. Kill Bill Volume 2 - $66,208,183
42. The Manchurian Candidate - $65,955,630
43. Barbershop 2: Back in Business - $65,111,277
44. Miracle - $64,378,093
45. Friday Night Lights - $61,227,060
46. The Stepford Wives - $59,484,742
47. Hellboy - $59,431,508
48. Dawn of the Dead - $58,990,765
49. Without a Paddle - $58,116,109
50. The Butterfly Effect - $57,938,693

(i will update the chart as much as possible!)

What films belong in the top 50 of 2004? which ones don't? Which ones should have been bombs? which one's shouldn't have? Discussion for the Domestic Top 50 of 2004.

Should Be on the List

Team America: World Police
Saw
The Chronicles of Riddick
Resident Evil: Apocalypse
Blade: Trinity
Garden State


Should Not Be on the List

The Village
Scooby-Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed
Garfield
The Stepford Wives
Miracle

It appears you got the films all in the right order, with the correct grosses, so I see no problem.

Should not be on the list:

Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban - $249,541,069
Fahrenheit 9/11 - $119,194,771
Anchorman - $85,224,248
Christmas with the Kranks - $73,283,281
White Chicks - $69,897,980

Should be on the list:

Catwoman
King Arthur
Saw
Shade

I hate thread like this. How can you say a movie "didnt deserve" what It made. I hate lots of movies, however that dosent mean it didnt deserve the money it garnered.

Damn, have you seen Anchorman? Funniest movie of the year.

I doubt he's seen most of the "do not deserve" films listed. And personally, I don't believe The Grudge deserves to be in the Top 50. Terrible, terrible movie.

Seriously guys... Why does a movie NOT deserve what it gets....

Everyone movie deserves what they got, but there's a difference between "what doesn't deserve to be there" and "what would you want different". This thread is basically asking what movies do you wish made more money, and what do you wish made less.

Ohhh....well that makes more sense

No i havent seen it, but i dont find Will Ferrel comedy funny at all, and it looks boring.

What should be on the list??

Before Sunrise $134,333,890
Garden State $109,870,780

I once thought Will Ferrel was pretty bland as an actor but really you should check out Old School and Anchorman. They are hilarious.

In actual fact, i am starting to agree with you, it wasnt all that good, left me wanting something else to happen, the end was bollocks thats for sure, also, how long can a boy in white face paint scare you?

Okay maybe i will How about Elf? that funny?

....because Elf is what made me think he was a prick, id seen countless adverts and commercials for Elf last xmas, and it fucking irritated me!!!!!

Elf was directed towards kids for godsake. what did you expect. I recomend you do catch them too flicks, quality viewing :wink:

Yes, thats something I can agree on - those are some good choices you mentioned! Also King Arthur should be at least in the Top 50!

I think that Garden State should have made much more.

Should Not
1. Shrek - $441,226,247

3. The Passion of the Christ - $370,274,604


9. Shark Tale - $160,824,920
10. The Polar Express - $156,065,725

12. I, Robot - $144,801,023

14. 50 First Dates - $120,908,074
15. Van Helsing - $120,177,084

18. The Village - $114,197,520


23. The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement - $95,170,481

25. Along Came Polly - $88,097,164

28. Scooby-Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed - $84,198,209
29. Spongebob Squarepants Movie - $82,143,196
30. The Notebook - $81,001,787
31. Alien vs. Predator - $80,282,231

35. Ladder 49 - $73,870,841
36. Christmas with the Kranks - $73,283,281

38. White Chicks - $69,897,980
49. Without a Paddle - $58,116,109
50. The Butterfly Effect - $57,938,693

Should Be There:
Sky Captain
Team America
Saved!
[/b]

Shouldnt have been there
9. Shark Tale - $160,824,920
25. Along Came Polly - $88,097,164
31. Alien vs. Predator - $80,282,231
36. Christmas with the Kranks - $73,283,281

Should have been there
13 GOING ON 30
HERO
ETERNAL SUNSHINE