if we do three, at least one defensive player needs to be mandatory, to your point

the scoring definitely needs fixing, btw.

i know smurfs is probably sad that lil' breezy only got him 11 points...but the fact that lil' breezy got 11 points at all is ridiculous. how do you get 11 points throwing 5 interceptions and 0 touchdowns? in my other league, that's 3.6 points!

clearly, an interception deserves more weight than simply two 'incompletions' for a qb or two 'tackles' for a defensive player. a tackle or incompletion itself does not result in a turnover; a fumble or an interception does.

here are my suggested changes in all areas, however crazy:
1) eliminate completion/ incompletion bonuses for qb's
2) eliminate yardage bonuses for qb's -- or, at least raise it to 300 yds (case in point -- drew brees got a yardage bonus today; matt ryan did not. those 10 pts made up for his 5 interceptions, putting both qb's even at 11 pts)
3) switch qb pass yardage earning from 50 yds/pt to 25 yds/pt
4) equalize points lost for a qb sack/ points gained for a defensive player sack at -2/2 (currently -1/3 or -1/2, respectively?)
5) make a 'defensive/ special teams' unit reflective of the title of the positions -- and allow for special team touchdowns
6) stop giving special team yardage credit to offensive roster players
7) make rushing and receiving TDs worth 8 pts (+2 over a passing TD)
8) increase value of a defensive player interception vis-a-vis a sack (it should be the same as the points from a fumble -- 1 for the fumble, 2 for the recovery, for 3 total)

oh, and add game-time waivers
and add trade review so we don't have to deal with fair stuff being rejected and causing a cycle of rejections
and for the record, there's a good chance i lose my place next season anyway since magnus likely won't rejoin, so you can ignore all these comments too

On a Side note I'm going to experiment with the settings a little over the next couple of minutes just to see how things would have turned out if settings were different. Everything will be put back to normal so don't worry.

i think you goofed changing the settings back, because now i'm 9-5, instead of 9-4-1. i think qb sacks are -1 in our league, not -2.

anyway, i like either of the settings. but i know i'm in the minority.

Right. Under the old settings, I was 9-4-1. Now I'm 9-5. It's because Thug didn't change the QB sack score back to -1. Because it's set to -2, I now lost to trixster. Doesn't really matter, but would be cool for it to be accurate!

So my team was awesome under all the rules.

Fixed

Looking at the poll 2 seems to be the most popular choice

Individual only.

I'm hoping I'm the one that knocks u out the playoffs

Keeper for next year looks decided:

2- Offensive
1- Defensive

Question on the Defensive is it only individual players or are team defenses included too?