Paul Giamatti is perfect as Barney.

Without him playing this rather obnoxious schlemiel, there would have been no way for viewers to end up falling in love with him, and thereby believing that his three wives could ever do so too. He sells Barney's Version.

The supporting actors are solid - - from the three wives, Minnie Driver (need to see more of her), Rachelle Lefevre, and Rosamund Pike to Scott Speedman who you'll remember from Underworld.

This two and a quarter hour movie might have benefited by being tightened up by cutting the extraneous murder story, but nonetheless I felt lucky to meet Barney and hear his version of his life story.


4 out of 5.

Absolutely loved this. Just my type in style, writing, acting, etc. I'm surprised this got passed over in awards season and general acclaim/hype. As far as I'm concerned it's one of last year's all around best and I wish I hadn't caught it at the end of its theatre run, I'd love to see it again

I loved it, too.

Based on the popular novel by the late Mordecai Richler, Barney’s Version is a comic and poignant film with terrific performances. The experience of watching it is as comfortable as a favorite sweater, as pleasant as a long conversation with old friends. In the title role, an often ill-tempered, but mostly kindhearted soap opera producer based in Montreal, Paul Giamatti delivers what might be his finest performance or at least one on par with his excellent turns in American Splendor and Sideways.

The film follows Barney Panofsky through his life, centering in particular on his three wives: Clara (Rachelle Lefevre), a bohemian he impregnates in Rome; the nameless "second Mrs. P." (Minnie Driver), an obnoxious Jewish princess; and, at last, Miriam (Rosamund Pike), the love of his life and mother of his children. We also see Barney's close relationship with his father (Dustin Hoffman), a tough retired policeman, as well as his friendship with Boogie (Scott Speedman), a substance-abusing writer who meets a suspicious end.

Just as excellent as Giamatti is Rosamund Pike (it's criminal neither was nominated for an Oscar). She's a radiant actress who has delivered fine turns in several films, including Die Another Day, Pride & Prejudice, Fracture, and An Education, but this is her best role to date. We follow Miriam as she goes from Barney's aloof object of affection to his devoted wife, and then, alas, as she grows tired of his incorrigible behavior. Pike breathes life into her every step of the way, turning a supporting character into one just as essential and fascinating as the actual protagonist. Dustin Hoffman is also deserving of praise. It is clear the veteran actor is having a great time playing Barney's advice-dispensing, B.S.-averse blue-collar father.

At well over two hours, it could be said Barney's Version is too long. The inclusion of a quirky murder mystery in particular might raise the ire of those hoping for a shorter, tighter film. But as Roger Ebert once wrote, "No good film is too long, no bad film is short enough." Here is a well-acted and crafted film full of humor and heartache. I could have easily spent another hour with Barney Panofsky and co.

A-

This was good, but felt overlong, IMO. Doesn't help that our main character is a mostly unlikable schlub. Rosamund Pike makes the movie. She's a lovely actress that I enjoy watching immensely, and she's wonderful here.

7/10 (B-)