I rated all of Taylor Swift's songs and had exactly 30 that I had as a 9 or higher.

You only get 1 guess at a time and then someone else has to go before you can again. Or if nobody else has guessed, but I have answered your guess, you can go again.

No Midnights songs as it's too early

Full list

1. All Too Well (10.0)
2. Breathe (9.5)
3. Long Live (9.5)
4. Hey Stephen (9.5)
5. Haunted (9.5)
6. Getaway Car (9.5)
7. Fifteen (9.5)
8. Fearless (9.5)
9. ivy (9.5)
10. Death By A Thousand Cuts (9.5)
11. London Boy (9.5)
12. cardigan (9.0)
13. Everything Has Changed (9.0)
14. Superman (9.0)
15. Out of the Woods (9.0)
16. The Way I Loved You (9.0)
17. Should've Said No (9.0)
18. You Belong With Me (9.0)
19. Forever And Always (9.0)
20. Ours (9.0)
21. betty (9.0)
22. Cruel Summer (9.0)
23. Safe and Sound (9.0)
24. All You Had To Do Is Stay (9.0)
25. hoax (9.0)
26. Paper Rings (9.0)
27. peace (9.0)
28. Mean (9.0)
29. cowboy like me (9.0)
30. Holy Ground (9.0)

Already guessed:

Taylor Swift:

Teardrops On My Guitar (7.5)
Our Song (8.5)

Fearless:

Love Story (8.0)
White Horse (7.5)
You're Not Sorry (6.0)
Jump Then Fall (6.5)
Mr. Perfectly Fine (6.5)

Speak Now:

Mine (8.5)
Better Than Revenge (8.0)
Sparks Fly (7.5)
Back to December (7.5)
The Story of Us (7.5)
Enchanted (6.5)
Innocent (6.0)
Dear John (6.0)

Red:

State of Grace (8.5)
Red (8.0)
We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together (7.5)
22 (7.0)
Treacherous (6.0)

1989:

Blank Space (8.5)
Shake It Off (8.0)
Style (7.5)
Wildest Dreams (7.5)
How You Get the Girl (7.0)
I Wish You Would (6.5)

Reputation:

End Game (8.5)
Delicate (8.5)
I Did Something Bad (7.5)
Call It What You Want (7.5)
... Ready For It? (7.0)
Gorgeous (6.0)

Lover:

Lover (8.0)
The Man (8.0)
Miss Americana and the Heartbreak Prince (8.0)
Cornelia Street (8.5)
Me! (7.5)
False Gold (6.5)

folklore:

the 1 (7.5)
this is me trying (6.0)
mirrorball (6.0)

evermore:

no body no crime (8.5)
exile (8.0)
tolerate it (8.0)
willow (7.0)

Movie:

Today Was A Fairytale (6.0)
I Don't Wanna Live Forever (5.0)

Our Song

Our Song (8.5) - Not on the list, but would be in the top 40 or so.

Hey Stephen

That's a big score right off the bat with a top 5 song that's at least a medium sized deep cut!

4. Hey Stephen (9.5)

Out of the Woods

Yes - one of my two highest rated 1989 tracks

15. Out of the Woods (9.0)

You Belong With Me

My next guess is Getaway Car.

Also, in the song Maroon, do you hear the words "Marc Gasol" instead of "mark you saw" in the chorus?

Not until you mentioned it, but she does have a long list of Starbucks lovers

6. Getaway Car (9.5)
18. You Belong With Me (9.0)

Another good call by Flava, and bold to pick Reputation since I just said in the other thread I have it as her weakest album.

Mine.

Flava'd proving his Swift skills I see.

I thought Mine was in my top 30, but it turns out I have it 33rd. “You made a rebel of a careless man’s careful daughter” is a 10, though.

Mine (8.5)

How about one of my faves, Sparks Fly

Nope

Sparks Fly (7.5)

All Too Well

Booooo

Ok, Cruel Summer

1. All Too Well (10)

The only perfect 10 on the list

22. Cruel Summer (9.0)

exile

First folklore/evermore guess - Not on list

exile - (8.0)

exile is the only great song on either of those albums

There are 6 combined for those albums on the list. Plus a few close cuts.

Enchanted

Enchanted (6.5)

Enchanted is probably the song I disagree most with the conventional wisdom, I was surprised to learn a few years ago how beloved it is among some Swifties, and easily has Speak Now's most spotify listens. This also affects my rating of Speak Now as it is one or two more classics away from being the outright second best album after Fearless.

End Game