
Re: Black Swan, True Grit, The Fighter scores disqualified
Price wrote:
The problem isn't on using classical pieces on a soundtrack as is the case of THE KING'S SPEECH. Desplat has composed original music for that film that isn't based on previously released material.
Mansell seems to have taken an existing piece of work and adapted and varied it into his score, and that hass been deemed ineligible since the Academy dropped the best adapted score category years ago due to a lack of candidates.
I haven't heard the scores either, but from what I read Mansell both varied the theme and wrote original music just as Desplat.
Price wrote:
I wonder if something similar can happen to Zimmer's INCEPTION and his usage of 'Non, Je ne regrette rien', but I think the 'percentage' of use is minimal compared to the other composed material.
I do believe Inception should follow the same fate because they did use Piaf song in the main theme that repeats over and over...
But it's the Oscar music branch.They're idiots most of the time.