I've finished all of them at last. Well, except for Make Mine Music which I couldn't find on D+ at the time, but honestly I think I'm fine without it. I'll go back and rewatch the others I had seen before at some point for a more definitive final list, but that might take awhile.

-Elite

1. Zootopia
2. Lion King
3. Frozen
4. Moana
5. The Great Mouse Detective
6. Aladdin
7. Tarzan
8. Beauty and the Beast
9. Ralph Breaks The Internet
10. Lady and the Tramp
11. One Hundred and One Dalmatians
12. Pinnochio
13. Raya and the Last Dragon
14. Meet The Robinsons

-Almost elite

15. The Hunchback of Notre Dame
16. Sleeping Beauty
17. Cinderella
18. Dumbo
19. Tangled
20. The Emporers New Groove
21. Lilo and Stitch
22. Big Hero 6
23. Winnie the Pooh

-Almost Almost Elite

24. Frozen 2
25. Hercules
26. Wreck It Ralph
27. Bolt
28. Oliver and Company

-Respect, but not as much

29. Snow White
30. Ichabod and Mr Toad
31. Mulan
32. Aristocats
33. Peter Pan
34. Brother Bear
35. The Jungle Book
36. Fun and Fancy Free

-Much less respect, but still a little

37. Pocohantis
38. The Little Mermaid
39. The Rescuers
40. Robin Hood
41. Atlantis
42. Treasure Planet
43. Home On The Range
44. Princess and the Frog

-Mehhh

45. Dinosaur
46. Alice In Wonderland
47. Bambi
48. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh
49. The Fox and the Hound
50. Fantasia 2000

-Gonna be a no from me dawg

51. Chicken Little
52. The Rescuers Down Under
53. The Black Cauldron
54. The Sword in the Stone
55. Fantasia
56. Melody Time
57. Saludos Amigos
58. Three Cabarellos

1. Big Hero 6
2. Zootopia
3. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh
4. The Lion King
5. Pocahontas
6. Lilo and Stitch
7. Frozen
8. Moana
9. Aladdin
10. The Jungle Book
11. Wreck-It Ralph

Tough because there so many. But my favorites for sure are:

Beauty and the Beast
Fantasia

and I am finally starting to warm up to the Lion King as elite tier

First tier:

Bambi
Snow White
Pinocchio
Sword in the Stone
Jungle Book
Little Mermaid
Cinderella
101 Dalmatians
Beauty and the Beast
Aladdin
Lion King
Frozen

Second tier:

Dumbo
Alice in Wonderland
Lady and the Tramp
Pocahontas
Princess and the Frog
Tangled
Wreck-It-Ralph
Zootopia
Encanto

1. Beauty and the Beast
2. Aladdin
3. The Little Mermaid
4 Peter Pan
5. 101 Dalmatians
6. Hercules
7. Tangled
8. Lilo and Stitch
9. Sleeping Beauty
10. The Hunchback of Notre Dame
11. The Emperor’s New Groove
12. Encanto
13. Pinocchio
14. Mulan
15. The Princess and the Frog
16. Moana
17. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh
18. The Lion King
19. Frozen
20. Wreck-It Ralph
22. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
23. Zootopia
24. Pocahontas
25. Cinderella
26. Frozen 2
27. The Great Mouse Detective
28. Meet the Robinsons
29. Ralph Breaks the Internet
30. Robin Hood
31. Wish
32. The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr Toad
33. Tarzan
34. Bambi
35. Winnie the Pooh
36. Lady and the Tramp
37. The Fox and the Hound
39. Alice in Wonderland
40. Fantasia
41. The Black Cauldron
42. Dumbo
43. Big Hero 6
44. Atlantis: The Lost Empire
45. Raya and the Last Dragon
46. Bolt
47. Brother Bear
48. The Rescuers
49. Oliver and Company
50. The Aristocats
51. Home on the Range
52. Fantasia 2000
53. The Rescuers Down Under
54. Strange World
55. The Jungle Book
56. The Sword in the Stone
57. Chicken Little
58. Fun and Fancy Free
59. Melody Time
60. Make Mine Music
61. Saludos Amigos
62. The Three Caballeros
63. Dinosaur

Why no love for Tarzan?

It’s never been a favorite it’s fine. Dont really like the Phil Collins songs.

Too low for OG Jungle Book

It is BORING. Plus the animation is ugly and cheap looking.

I haven’t seen it in ages but I love the I Wanna Be Like You sequence and ending

Wish is easily bottom tier. I'd have a hard time ranking the older Disney films from pre-90s.

One recent film I want to rewatch is Raya, barely remember it

Have you not seen them, or just don’t have strong opinions?

Other than Pinocchio and Snow White I didn't really grow up watching the older ones and when I rewatch them they kind of don't make that strong an impression other than the animation. Guess its the nostalgia factor.

Aw man, I thought Big Hero 6 was fantastic. Shame you didn't enjoy it as much. Then again, looking at your list with The Little Mermaid and Beauty and the Beast in the top five, are you pre- or post-op?

I kid, I kid. Couldn't resist.

this is hard. there's sooo many top tier movies.
It's hard enough to rank the amazing run of TLM, BATB, Aladdin and TLK let alone the ones before and after

I think the only Disney movies that would earn a top tier from me are Fantasia, Beauty and the Beast and reluctantly The Lion King.

Others like Hunchback, Pinocchio, and a few others come close but are held back for various reasons (maybe Aladdin goes here?)

Then there is a slew of quality films that just don’t have that It factor enough.

Finally a slew of boring films like The Aristocats.

Last at the bottom are the real stinkers like Chicken Little. Disney doesn’t make these often unless they try something against brand and find themselves out of their element like when they tried to make a modern CGI movie before John Lesseter joined them ie Chicken Little.