Register  |  Sign In
20 Favorite Living Male Movie Stars

Here is a list of my twenty favorite living movie stars.  Why the rule they must be alive?  To be honest, so I can be more playful.  If one tries to create a list based on the entire history of cinema, there are so many titans one can't ignore, from Chaplin and Keaton to Bogart to Brando, and it just becomes a staid recreation of the American Film Institute's 100 Stars list (a good list, though ignoring Steve McQueen was criminal).

My original plan was to justify each inclusion with a paragraph or two, but it became tedious, and I found I was often repeating myself.  Most of them I consider dramatic actors of the highest order.  A few comic geniuses, too.  And the list begins with the man I would dub the reigning king of the modern action film.  In general, the words "movie star," in my mind, indicate talent, of course, but also mystique, a certain fiery, larger-than-life x factor.

I tried to be very honest with the list.  For examle, Clint Eastwood is not on it because, at the end of the day, he is not among my twenty favorite male movie stars.  It would be foolish and dishonest to push actors I find more fascinating, engaging, and/or entertaining from the list just to include him on the grounds he is a veteran and an icon.

Please feel free to leave comments: agree, disagree, post your own personal favorites, angrily point out the list needs more actors of color, etc.

20. Jason Statham

Two Essential Films Snatch, The Transporter

Next Movie The Expendables 2

19. Christian Bale

Two Essential Films American Psycho, The Fighter

Next Movie The Dark Knight Rises

18. Edward Norton

Two Essential Films American History X, Fight Club

Next Movie The Bourne Legacy

17. Benicio Del Toro

Two Essential Films 21 Grams, Che

Next Movie Savages

16. Michael Fassbender

Two Essential Films Jane Eyre, Shame

Next Movie Prometheus

15. Jude Law

Two Essential Films The Talented Mr. Ripley, A.I. Artificial Intelligence

Next Movie 360

14. Sean Connery

Two Essential Films From Russia with Love, The Name of the Rose

Next Movie - (Retired, though it is hard not to wish he could play one more fantastic role and not end his iconic screen career with LXG)

13. George Clooney

Two Essential Films O Brother, Where Art Thou?, Syriana

Next Movie Gravity

12. Javier Bardem

Two Essential Films The Sea Inside, No Country for Old Men

Next Movie Skyfall

11. Robert Redford

Two Essential Films The Sting, Out of Africa

Next Movie The Company You Keep

10. Michael Caine

Two Essential Films the original Get Carter, Hannah and Her Sisters

Next Movie The Dark Knight Rises

9. Bill Murray

Two Essential Films Ghostbusters, Lost in Translation

Next Movie Hyde Park on Hudson

8. Jim Carrey

Two Essential Films The Truman Show, A Christmas Carol

Next Movie The Incredible Burt Wonderstone

7. Tom Cruise

Two Essential Films Born on the Fourth of July, Collateral

Next Movie Rock of Ages

6. Clive Owen

Two Essential Films Closer, Children of Men

Next Movie Shadow Dancer

5. Russell Crowe

Two Essential Films The Insider, Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World

Next Movie Les Misérables

4. Ewan McGregor

Two Essential Films Trainspotting, Beginners

Next Movie The Impossible

3. Leonardo DiCaprio

Two Essential Films Catch Me If You Can, Inception

Next Movie Django Unchained

2. Colin Farrell

Two Essential Films The New World, In Bruges

Next Movie Total Recall

1. Nicolas Cage

Two Essential Films Leaving Las Vegas, Adaptation.

Next Movie Stolen

No, you have not entered the Twilight Zone.  Or perhaps you have.  Either way, yes, I have placed Nicolas Cage at no. 1 on this list.  Yes, he has done several bad films.  When Russell Crowe does a bad film, it tends to be along the lines of Proof of Life or Body of Lies, admirable failures by respected directors.  When Cage does a bad film, it's THE BEES!  But when Cage is good, in particular when he's good and in a film by a director willing to push the envelope and experiment (such as David Lynch in Wild at Heart or Joel and Ethan Coen in Raising Arizona), there is a magic I'm not sure the other men on this list can generate.  A mad, mystical, and electric magic, the acting equivalent of Hunter S. Thompson's writing or the Beatles recording "I Am the Walrus."  Even in mediocre B movies (Next, for example, or Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance), there are brief moments of wild-eyed genius which indicate you the moviegoer are in the presence of a man with a significant and unique talent, even if it is a talent he often fails to control or concentrate the way we wish he would.

-

The average age of the actors on this list is 49.  They range in age from the 35-year-old Fassbender to the 81-year-old Connery.

Seven are American.  Four are English.  Two are Scottish.  Two are Irish, though Fassbender was born in Germany.  One is Welsh, though identifies as English (Bale).  One is Canadian.  One is a New Zealand born Australian.  One is Spanish.  One is Puerto Rican.

Fifteen have been nominated for at least one Oscar.  Cage, Crowe, Caine, Redford, Bardem, Clooney, Connery, Del Toro, and Bale have won an Oscar.  Only Caine has won twice, both for Best Supporting Actor.  Jim Carrey has won two Golden Globes, for The Truman Show and Man on the Moon, in addition to five other nominations, but has not yet been nominated for an Oscar.

Three of the top ten highest grossing films in history include at least one of these actors.  DiCaprio is in Titanic.  Bale and Caine are in The Dark Knight.  McGregor is in Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace.  Every actor on the list had been in at least one $100 million hit.  Bardem, Del Toro, and Owen only once: Collateral, Traffic, and The Bourne Identity, respectively.  Cruise has been in seventeen: Top Gun, Rain Man, A Few Good Men, The Firm, Interview with the Vampire, Mission: Impossible, Jerry Maguire, Mission: Impossible II, Vanilla Sky, Minority Report, Austin Powers in Goldmember, The Last Samurai, Collateral, War of the Worlds, Mission: Impossible III, Tropic Thunder, and Mission: Impossible - Ghost Protocol.

Login to Comment
Total Comments: 9
Arthur A.
Arthur A.    Jun 5 2012 6:46am
Hard to argue with this list.

However...Jane Eyre but not Hunger as Fassbender's essential film?
David Holmes
David Holmes    Jun 5 2012 6:51am
I was definitely going to include Shame from the start. I could have also included the terrific Hunger, yes, but then it almost seemed too one-note. Both Steve McQueen films where he gives extremely physical, unsettling dramatic performances. Jane Eyre, where he shows a more dashing and romantic side (and creates a definitive screen version of a literary character actors as considerable as Orson Welles and William Hurt have also played), seemed a solid option for the second film. I also considered Fish Tank, to be honest.
David Holmes
David Holmes    Jun 5 2012 7:01am
For the record: with many of the actors, I tried to choose two films which reflect different parts of their overall abilities. Born on the Fourth of July for Cruise the -serious actor- (so tempted to choose Magnolia), and Collateral for Cruise the ice-cold, charismatic, confident -movie star-. The Truman Show for the Jim Carrey who is so good at delivering earnest, poignant comic/dramatic performances in the vein of James Stewart, and A Christmas Carol for the Carrey who is a character-and-impressions-oriented comedian with a certain elastic quality.
David Holmes
David Holmes    Jun 5 2012 7:27am
Also, in general, I hoped to move away from the type of list I always see. De Niro, Eastwood, Nicholson, Pacino, Poitier, rinse, repeat. I have huge respect for those men, but it's always the same. I wanted to compile a list which said, "Ewan McGregor has been delivering interesting and valuable performances for almost 20 years now. Can we start to place him and his generation in the context of this type of list? Can we maybe start to recognize Crowe's best performances rival Pacino's? Or maybe begin to ponder if Bardem is every bit the actor De Niro was at the height of his powers?"
Karl Schneider
Karl Schneider    Jun 5 2012 11:02am
Cage? CAGE?!

Ugh. I get what you're saying, but I still can't stand him.
Arthur A.
Arthur A.    Jun 6 2012 9:28am
Also, David, I love Cage, but it seems unfair towards his essential films (which were very good, no doubt) not to incude at least one of his golden-age actioners like The Rock, Face Off or Con Air...
David Holmes
David Holmes    Jun 7 2012 1:17am
If I had included five films, they would have been Raising Arizona, Leaving Las Vegas, Face/Off, Adaptation., and The Weather Man (extremely underrated).
Mike
Mike    Jun 9 2012 10:56pm
Cage being #1 is a joke ;). But it's your list. He has given great performances in the past but I really can't stand him anymore. Though I agree The Weather Man is underrated.
Algren
Algren    Dec 18 2012 12:05am
Tom Cruise, Bale, Clive Owen, Clooney, Cage and Farrell are the best picks. Good list.